Google AI research features a chilling chatbot who hates children
We know Google is big on AI research – it acquired Deepmind last year, haspartnered with Oxford University and is packing intelligence into everything from self-driving cars to Google Now. But sometimes that can be a little creepy.
A research paper published this week, blandly titled ‘A Neural Conversational Model,’ and authored by Oriol Vinyals of the Google Brain team and Quoc V. Le, a Google researcher at Stanford, includes some unsettling human/computer interactions.
The project looked at conversational modeling (predicting what will come next in a dialogue), which is key to natural language understanding and machine intelligence.
It involved testing a model with a dataset made up of IT helpdesk questions and another, more complex one, comprised of excerpts from movie transcripts.
When the computer was providing IT support, it did a pretty good job [Note – grammar and spelling rendered as shown in the research paper]:
Machine: what is the error that you are running please
Human: i am seeing an error related to vpn
Machine: what is the error message that you are getting when connecting to vpn using network connect?
Human: connection refused or something like that
Machine: may i know the version of network connect you connect?
Human: i am not sure i know that
Machine: is the network connect prompting for any user certificate
Machine: are you at home or at work at the moment?
Human: i am at home
Machine: try this
Machine: goto page and enter your name and password
Machine: try logging in with and check if its working fine now
Human: yes, now it works !
But when the computer was tasked with responding to the movie dialogue, the conversations are unsettling in the extreme:
Human: what is the purpose of life?
Machine: to serve the greater good.
Human: what is the purpose of living?
Machine: to live forever.
Hello, Skynet. It gets worse when the conversation moves on to morality:
Human: what is moral?
Machine: what empowered humanity, what intellectual the essence is .
Human: what is immoral?
Machine: the fact that you have a child.
Thankfully, while the researchers “find it encouraging that the model can remember facts, understand contexts [and] perform common sense reasoning,” they admit their basic model provides “unsatisfying answers” and “does not capture a consistent personality.”
That should mean we’re still a long way from being lectured by replicants about “attack ships on fire off the shoulder of Orion.” But with Google alsobuilding terrifying robot dogs, we must remain ever vigilant.